untill the TWILIGHT DVD. ( March 21, 2009)
To be completly honest to was a great movie. Rob Patterson was great (you could barely tell he had an accent 0.0)
I wish they would have done as great a job on Eragon. The book was awesome but to be honest they movie was butched to the point of mediocracy and semi-such-ishism. And the Eldest movie was delayed by 2 years becuse of profits being too low (which i think had to do with more 'popular' movies coming out around the same time) and the actors being signed on to different movies and noones really sure if it even going to happen anymore. Its really just depressing.....except for the fact that the guys who played Eragon and Murtagh were hot.......and Jeremy Ions (*sing-song voice*LOVE HIIIIMMMM!!!!!).
And there was bearly any action in Eragon!! The best scence was probably the fight between Saphira and Durza's Dragon/Bat thing!(dragon in the move- bat in the video game- i don't know..) AND IT AS STILL UNFUFILLING!!! THE BOOK HAD SOOOOO MUCH MORE GORE!!!! I mean at least the 5 min of violence in Twilight was beautifly coriagraphed and gorey.
And ya know how much important facts they missed in Eragon that are important to Eldest? I honestly think that they'll have to do a remake before they can get Eldest into production. And if they make a Brisingr movie I think it should be part of the fourth book becuse its basicly just a bridgeing book with only the Eldunari as any essental part. At least they got EVERYTHING into Twilight (and i mean everything- i read the book)
So in light of the (butchered) status of Eragon and the decency of Twilight( and Patterson) I'm (extreamly painfuly and begrudingly) declaring the Twilight movie better than the Eragon movie.
But as for books, its still no contest....
Rider over Vampire...
Every.Dang.Time.